If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Chamonix accidents
You have probably heard the news of the two tragic accidents last
weekend. The Vallée Blanche accident is really sad and could probably happen to any of us but when people ski in high altitude off-piste ski areas should they not accept that there are risks. The mountains are certainly a dangerous playground and one should not forget this. What do you think of the following piece: http://www.roundhaytoday.co.uk/news/...tim.3844817.jp PS. There are actually very clear sign that are impossible to miss when you get to the top of the Aiguille du Midi warning people that it is a very dangerous area and not a piste. |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Chamonix accidents
On Thu, 6 Mar 2008 11:25:46 -0800 (PST), in
, French_Skier wrote: What do you think of the following piece: http://www.roundhaytoday.co.uk/news/...tim.3844817.jp Load of uninformed twaddle, innit? Skiing/boarding is a dangerous activity and anyone taking part needs to be aware of this. In Chamonix it's virtually impossible, unless you walk around with your eyes closed, to see the high level of safety precautions taken by most serious skiers, and you'd have to be very stupid indeed to be unaware of the risk, or at least that there may be risk you don't fully understand. PS. There are actually very clear sign that are impossible to miss when you get to the top of the Aiguille du Midi warning people that it is a very dangerous area and not a piste. There are signs all over the place, as I recall. What the family member quoted seems to want would be a US-style rigid enforcement of "safe" area skiing only, which, all else apart, runs completely counter to the French ideal of the 'Montagne Libre'. Very sad when someone dies like this, of course, but really there's no point in trying to pin the blame on someone else. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Chamonix accidents
Ace wrote:
On Thu, 6 Mar 2008 11:25:46 -0800 (PST), in , French_Skier wrote: What do you think of the following piece: http://www.roundhaytoday.co.uk/news/...tim.3844817.jp Load of uninformed twaddle, innit? Skiing/boarding is a dangerous activity and anyone taking part needs to be aware of this. In Chamonix it's virtually impossible, unless you walk around with your eyes closed, to see the high level of safety precautions taken by most serious skiers, and you'd have to be very stupid indeed to be unaware of the risk, or at least that there may be risk you don't fully understand. PS. There are actually very clear sign that are impossible to miss when you get to the top of the Aiguille du Midi warning people that it is a very dangerous area and not a piste. There are signs all over the place, as I recall. What the family member quoted seems to want would be a US-style rigid enforcement of "safe" area skiing only, which, all else apart, runs completely counter to the French ideal of the 'Montagne Libre'. Very sad when someone dies like this, of course, but really there's no point in trying to pin the blame on someone else. Seems to be the British disease though these days - whenever anything 'bad' happens these days it's always someone else's fault..... |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Chamonix accidents
On 7 Mar, 08:48, " cupra" wrote:
Ace wrote: On Thu, 6 Mar 2008 11:25:46 -0800 (PST), in , French_Skier wrote: What do you think of the following piece: http://www.roundhaytoday.co.uk/news/...ski-victim.384... Load of uninformed twaddle, innit? Skiing/boarding is a dangerous activity and anyone taking part needs to be aware of this. In Chamonix it's virtually impossible, unless you walk around with your eyes closed, to see the high level of safety precautions taken by most serious skiers, and you'd have to be very stupid indeed to be unaware of the risk, or at least that there may be risk you don't fully understand. PS. There are actually very clear sign that are impossible to miss when you get to the top of the Aiguille du Midi warning people that it is a very dangerous area and not a piste. There are signs all over the place, as I recall. What the family member quoted seems to want would be a US-style rigid enforcement of "safe" area skiing only, which, all else apart, runs completely counter to the French ideal of the 'Montagne Libre'. Very sad when someone dies like this, of course, but really there's no point in trying to pin the blame on someone else. Seems to be the British disease though these days - whenever anything 'bad' happens these days it's always someone else's fault.....- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - Strikes me that it's some local rag journalist sensationalising a story that should be reported with a straight bat. Sounds like he's spinning quotes from an understandably upset relative who may not have been to the Alps, let alone skied them. Resorts are treading a thin line sometimes - they've got to make everyone aware of the dangers, but freeride is what brings in the punters, especially in places like Chamonix and Tignes and Val, so they don't want to put everyone off. I reckon they mostly get the balance right. In the Espace Killy the local radio stations tell you every hour in English and in French "It's an avalanche risk of X, so if you're going off piste make sure you have a shovel, probe and transceiver, know how to use them and never go off piste alone. If you want more advise go to the freeride chalet at the Col du Palet where you can learn to use a transceiver for free." - they give this little speech regardless of whether the risk is 1 or 5 or in between. All the safety stations additionally have blackboard right in front of the exits to the lifts that state the risk, plus additional info on wind slabs and pack stability. If it's not safe they have a big "STAY ON PISTE!", again in French, English and usually Italian and Spanish. And that's before you get to the yellow and black signs, ropes and 'closed' signs. Does everyone pay attention? No, but then it's personal choice and, as long as they're not about to set off a slide above an open piste, they can dice with their lives if they want. Slightly more sober account off the VB tragedy on pistehors.com where you could also read similarly tragic stories and people playing the blame game. Matt |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Chamonix accidents
Slightly more sober account off the VB tragedy on pistehors.com where you could also read similarly tragic stories and people playing the blame game. Matt- Hide quoted text - Found a photo of the Vallee Blanche warning sign on http://david.geraldine.club.fr/Piste...he-warning.jpg Not sure what else can be done to warn people of the danger apart from totally closing the down the Aiguille du Midi which would obviously be stupid. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Chamonix accidents
On Fri, 7 Mar 2008 08:48:30 -0000, " cupra"
wrote: Very sad when someone dies like this, of course, but really there's no point in trying to pin the blame on someone else. Seems to be the British disease though these days - whenever anything 'bad' happens these days it's always someone else's fault..... Just a 'media disease', I think. -- Champ neal at champ dot org dot uk |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Chamonix accidents
In message
, Matt T writes If it's not safe they have a big "STAY ON PISTE!", again in French, English and usually Italian and Spanish. And that's before you get to the yellow and black signs, ropes and 'closed' signs. Does everyone pay attention? No, but then it's personal choice and, as long as they're not about to set off a slide above an open piste, they can dice with their lives if they want. Did you see the Darwin Award nomination for two North Americans (one skis, one board) who passed four warning signs and a fence to enter a closed area and get themselves avalanched? The Darwin judges said the stupidity itself was too common to earn an award but the four signs got it special consideration. -- Sue ] |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Chamonix accidents
On 8 Mar, 22:09, MadCow wrote:
In message , Matt T writes If it's not safe they have a big "STAY ON PISTE!", again in French, English and usually Italian and Spanish. And that's before you get to the yellow and black signs, ropes and 'closed' signs. Does everyone pay attention? No, but then it's personal choice and, as long as they're not about to set off a slide above an open piste, they can dice with their lives if they want. Did you see the Darwin Award nomination for two North Americans (one skis, one board) who passed four warning signs and a fence to enter a closed area and get themselves avalanched? The Darwin judges said the stupidity itself was too common to earn an award but the four signs got it special consideration. -- Sue *] As I was reading that I was thinking "Surely that's too common an occurence to earn an award." Happens every year here - people get sloppy, they've jumped that fence before, done that slope before and can see tracks made that morning, so figure it's safe. They don't know enough to take account of the time of day, way the slope's facing and what that's done to the snow that, frankly, could easily have slipped when those first tracks were made. Quick way to an early grave. Matt |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Chamonix accidents
On Fri, 7 Mar 2008 08:51:11 -0800 (PST), French_Skier
wrote: Found a photo of the Vallee Blanche warning sign on http://david.geraldine.club.fr/Piste...he-warning.jpg I love going past that sign :-) The most obvious one is on the italian helbronner side, where you have to go through a gate with the sign right next to it. -- Champ neal at champ dot org dot uk |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
St gervais and Chamonix | COlm | European Ski Resorts | 3 | December 21st 04 03:35 PM |
chamonix | jss | European Ski Resorts | 0 | November 15th 04 03:39 PM |
Val D'Isere to Chamonix | Linda | European Ski Resorts | 1 | March 26th 04 10:17 AM |
don't go to Chamonix ! | robespierra | European Ski Resorts | 7 | January 24th 04 07:41 PM |
don't go to Chamonix ! | Sue | Alpine Skiing | 2 | January 22nd 04 12:14 AM |