If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Help - I can't feel my toes!
I'm 33, brand new skier, 5'9", 180 pounds, street shoe 10.5 to 11,
slightly wide (can't wear Nikes). My feet pronate significantly (3.5 degrees left, 3 degrees right), which naturally means I have either flat feet or fallen arches (not sure how to tell which), and my legs are externally rotated. I also have an irritated sciatic nerve from a back injury last summer. I spent a weekend at Sunday River last year and had a blast. This Christmas, I went again, and after just a few hours my feet were killing me in the rental boots, so I decided to take the plunge and buy a pair. Buster Bean at the ski shop tried me in a few boots from Nordica, Technica, and I think Atomic before settling on a pair of size 27 Performa 7's. I skied a few runs in them, and went back to have them adjusted; another salesman added some SBS shims to help my pronation, which really helped my balance. This weekend I went to Sugarloaf, and within an hour of putting on the boots, my (nonexistent) arches were in agony, and my pinky and ring toes were numb. I went to the ski shop, which has won some sort of "best bootfitting" award from Ski magazine, and Russ spent about four hours with me, blowing out the toes, cutting the SBS shims better (they were curling), adding a heel shim, and heating the boots. I was still getting numb after 15 minutes or so in the store, but we figured it was time to try a few runs to loosen them up. So the next morning I went out, and while the arch pain was mostly gone, my toes were still getting numb after an hour or two. Back to the shop. I didn't feel the boots pressing anywhere except the ankle, so Russ ground the ankles. Went back out, still getting numb. Came back, and Russ was gone, so Ian helped me. We tried a few things, and finally, I asked - is it possible that the boots themselves are the wrong size? Sure enough, they were too loose; I should really be in a 26. They won't normally exchange boots from one ASC shop to another, but the manager was coming in the next morning and could do it. I decided to take advantage of the opportunity and upgrade to X-Wave 8's since I knew I'd outgrow the Performas rapidly. At first they were agony, but after swapping the footbeds for wintergreen Superfeet they were wonderful. Monday morning: Manager exchanges the boots for me. We put in the Superfeet and I hit the slopes for a few hours - sans SBS shims since they won't fit yet. Big improvement in control, but my outer toes are still numb. Back to the shop, where Ian blows out the toes, grinds the ankles, and heats the boots. Still numb. Adds back the heel shims temporarily, since outer numbness can be from pronation stressing the metatarsals. Still numb! I have to catch a bus to go home, so I don't get to hit the shop on my way off the slopes. I am really frustrated with this. What, if anything, can I do? Options include: - Just ski through the pain for 5-10 days before revisiting it. The boots are new and relatively stiff, and both the boots and footbeds will adjust to my feet. And once the boots expand, I can reinsert the SBS shims. - Try custom footbeds. Ian doesn't recommend this; he says that footbeds improve performance but diminish comfort compared to Superfeet since they're firmer. - Try orthopedic footbeds. Apparently there are some things doctors can do that ski shops aren't allowed to do in terms of shaping. Again, Ian recommends against. - Try a fancy shop with the scanning machine. Internet FAQs make these sound fairly common, but Russ said that they were only at "super- specialized" shops for high-performance skiing. - Something else... Help! Ideas? -- Jay Levitt | Wellesley, MA | Hi! Faster: jay at jay dot eff-em | Where are we going? http://www.jay.fm | Why am I in this handbasket? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Jay Levitt wrote:
I'm 33, brand new skier, 5'9", 180 pounds, street shoe 10.5 to 11, slightly wide (can't wear Nikes). My feet pronate significantly (3.5 degrees left, 3 degrees right), which naturally means I have either flat feet or fallen arches (not sure how to tell which), and my legs are externally rotated. I also have an irritated sciatic nerve from a back injury last summer. I spent a weekend at Sunday River last year and had a blast. This Christmas, I went again, and after just a few hours my feet were killing me in the rental boots, so I decided to take the plunge and buy a pair. Buster Bean at the ski shop tried me in a few boots from Nordica, Technica, and I think Atomic before settling on a pair of size 27 Performa 7's. I skied a few runs in them, and went back to have them adjusted; another salesman added some SBS shims to help my pronation, which really helped my balance. This weekend I went to Sugarloaf, and within an hour of putting on the boots, my (nonexistent) arches were in agony, and my pinky and ring toes were numb. I went to the ski shop, which has won some sort of "best bootfitting" award from Ski magazine, and Russ spent about four hours with me, blowing out the toes, cutting the SBS shims better (they were curling), adding a heel shim, and heating the boots. I was still getting numb after 15 minutes or so in the store, but we figured it was time to try a few runs to loosen them up. So the next morning I went out, and while the arch pain was mostly gone, my toes were still getting numb after an hour or two. Back to the shop. I didn't feel the boots pressing anywhere except the ankle, so Russ ground the ankles. Went back out, still getting numb. Came back, and Russ was gone, so Ian helped me. We tried a few things, and finally, I asked - is it possible that the boots themselves are the wrong size? Sure enough, they were too loose; I should really be in a 26. They won't normally exchange boots from one ASC shop to another, but the manager was coming in the next morning and could do it. I decided to take advantage of the opportunity and upgrade to X-Wave 8's since I knew I'd outgrow the Performas rapidly. At first they were agony, but after swapping the footbeds for wintergreen Superfeet they were wonderful. Stock footbeds in boots are generally made to be replaced. I have used Superfeet in the past with some degree of comfort but still prefer custom foot beds. Read further down. Yes, X-Wave 8's WILL have a significant improvement in performance over the Performas. The 8's should also be stiff enough for the next several years of skiing which, as you guessed, the Performas simply wouldn't. Monday morning: Manager exchanges the boots for me. We put in the Superfeet and I hit the slopes for a few hours - sans SBS shims since they won't fit yet. Big improvement in control, but my outer toes are still numb. Back to the shop, where Ian blows out the toes, grinds the ankles, and heats the boots. Still numb. Adds back the heel shims temporarily, since outer numbness can be from pronation stressing the metatarsals. Still numb! I have to catch a bus to go home, so I don't get to hit the shop on my way off the slopes. Numbness in extremities may be due to pressure further up your foot/ ankle. Someone who REALLY knows what they are doing can diagnose and correct this. I am really frustrated with this. What, if anything, can I do? Options include: First, since you have upgraded and resized you boots, I have to assume that the shell fit is correct, then... - Just ski through the pain for 5-10 days before revisiting it. The boots are new and relatively stiff, and both the boots and footbeds will adjust to my feet. And once the boots expand, I can reinsert the SBS shims. Although the liner of the boots will pack out some during the life of the boot, plastic, since it's resilient, does not "break-in" like leather. IMO don't try to "tough it out". It's not worth the pain and you may cause some damage that will give pain even after the boot is fitting OK. Ask me, I know. Tried some boots which I KNEW were too narrow. Damage on the outside knuckle prevents me from wearing my favorite boots which fit right and make me use my OLD (3 years) boots that are really too loose. - Try custom footbeds. Ian doesn't recommend this; he says that footbeds improve performance but diminish comfort compared to Superfeet since they're firmer. Custom footbeds, as you might get from SureFoot (as I did) or another boot/foot specialty shop will NOT give diminished comfort compared to Superfeet footbeds. The improvement in fit will ADD to comfort. - Try orthopedic footbeds. Apparently there are some things doctors can do that ski shops aren't allowed to do in terms of shaping. Again, Ian recommends against. As I understand it, someone who is licensed to make "orthotics" or orthotic foot beds can correct some of the mis-shape in you feet, namely the flatness where custom foot beds only hold your feet to the shape they are most comfortable with. I've never had true orthotics in my boots, only in my walking shoes. Again, what I said about custom foot beds. - Try a fancy shop with the scanning machine. Internet FAQs make these sound fairly common, but Russ said that they were only at "super- specialized" shops for high-performance skiing. Clearly the shop you went to doesn't have a scanning machine, otherwise, "Russ" would be extolling its virtues. Right? AND if boot/foot shops were "super-specialized" for "high- performance skiing" there wouldn't be so many of them. Right? There are so many of them because they do a good job of making skiing comfortable for the large mass of general skiers. I've found two so far. One is SureFoot at Killington, but be aware that not all SureFoot stores (it's a chain) are created equal. And Tahoe Boot 'n Ski Works in South Lake Tahoe, CA. Now, there are truly "high-end" bootfitters. There is one in Aspen whose name escapes me and Greg Hoffman at Green Mountain Orthotics Lab http://www.gmolfoot.com/ who not only makes your boots fit correctly, he can shape your boots so that you/your legs align correctly with your skis. GMOL is right at the mountain at Stratton so that you actually ski with the fitter as the work progresses. I've had friends who have had Greg work on their boots but I have not felt the need. - Something else... That pretty much covers it. There are the options, see where you want to go. Monique on rec.skiing.alpine.moderated has had a fairly lengthy thread on her tales of woe and wails of toe about her boot fitting episodes. Curiously enough, she also bought X-Wave (8 I think) boots. There is a certain amount of work involved in getting boots to fit right and be comfortable, especially for people with feet like yours and mine. I'm not satisfied until I can wear my boots for 8 hours straight and get up the next morning and do it again. Help! Ideas? |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Jay Levitt wrote:
In article , says... - Try custom footbeds. Ian doesn't recommend this; he says that footbeds improve performance but diminish comfort compared to Superfeet since they're firmer. Custom footbeds, as you might get from SureFoot (as I did) or another boot/foot specialty shop will NOT give diminished comfort compared to Superfeet footbeds. The improvement in fit will ADD to comfort. That's what I would think, too, and I was surprised.. maybe there are different types of custom insoles and he was speaking to the ones that the ASC shops install. Googling here, I did see a post from "Doug" on 3/7/03 that seemed to say Surefoot was useless, though it wasn't clear why... search Google Groups for "computer-image uncorrected-foot" to find it. - Try a fancy shop with the scanning machine. Internet FAQs make these sound fairly common, but Russ said that they were only at "super- specialized" shops for high-performance skiing. Clearly the shop you went to doesn't have a scanning machine, otherwise, "Russ" would be extolling its virtues. Right? Precisely... Also, he's been doing this for 30 years, and I get the idea he doesn't trust newfangled technology. I've seen that in a variety of trades; people like the old ways of doing things and trusting their "experience" vs. actual measurement. Me, I want to get a real-time 3D computer-enhanced holographic image of everything I can. Custom foot beds have been available in some form for at least 20 years. I've had them in my boots for 15 years. There is nothing particularly new here. Oh, maybe the use of a computer to determine the best fit, but we always had ways of molding a foot bed to your foot. My first one was made from an impression of my foot and then molded in cork. Worked great for 10 years. I've had one other set made by manual means and my latest are SureFoot which is not really a totally custom footbed. They have a range of about 150 patterns in all sizes. The computer simply decides which one is the best fit. For me this was good enough, but other shops can and do make full- on custom foot beds. I've found two so far. One is SureFoot at Killington, but be aware that not all SureFoot stores (it's a chain) are created equal. No problem - Killington is just a few hours away. Now, there are truly "high-end" bootfitters. There is one in Aspen whose name escapes me and Greg Hoffman at Green Mountain Orthotics Lab http://www.gmolfoot.com/ who not only makes your boots fit correctly, he can shape your boots so that you/your legs align correctly with your skis. GMOL is right at the mountain at Stratton Wowza. Stratton is 2.5 hours from me. I think it's time for a day trip. I've heard them mentioned here before, and only in glowing terms. Thanks for the advice. I'll give GMOL a call tomorrow. It might be a great idea to get an evaluation from Greg Hoffman, but his service may be just more than you can justify. You've already spent in the vicinity of $400 for boots. He'll ask you to spend that much or more again. It'll be up to you to decide if it's worth it. You probably wouldn't do badly to go to the bootfitter that Dave Stallard recommended in Brookline. My advice would be to find a good guy and stick with him, personally. Find out his schedule and plan return trips when he's there. SureFoot, as you may have heard, and I said earlier, has a spotty record. I'm delighted with my custom inner soles and I have feet at least as difficult as yours. One pair of boots came out of fitting beautifully and one pair is just plain too narrow and will never work, but the inner soles will go into another pair of boots. If you should come to Killington's SureFoot, ask for "Ray", he's the manager. If he's not in, find out when he will be in. The other guys seem to me to be seasonal employees with not enough experience. VtSkier |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Also Sprach VtSkier :
I've found two so far. One is SureFoot at Killington, but be aware that not all SureFoot stores (it's a chain) are created equal. And Tahoe Boot 'n Ski Works in South Lake Tahoe, CA. Now, there are truly "high-end" bootfitters. There is one in Aspen whose name escapes me and Greg Hoffman at Green Mountain Orthotics Lab http://www.gmolfoot.com/ who not only makes your boots fit correctly, he can shape your boots so that you/your legs align correctly with your skis. GMOL is right at the mountain at Stratton so that you actually ski with the fitter as the work progresses. I've had friends who have had Greg work on their boots but I have not felt the need. Treated my Pop to a fitting at GMOL last Christmas. He's always had a poor fit in stock boots, and was at the point where he would only ski 3 or 4 runs a day because of the pain. He can now be out all day with no problem. Dan -- Most people wouldn't know music if it came up and bit them on the ass. -- Frank Zappa |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Marshall Banana wrote:
Also Sprach VtSkier : I've found two so far. One is SureFoot at Killington, but be aware that not all SureFoot stores (it's a chain) are created equal. And Tahoe Boot 'n Ski Works in South Lake Tahoe, CA. Now, there are truly "high-end" bootfitters. There is one in Aspen whose name escapes me and Greg Hoffman at Green Mountain Orthotics Lab http://www.gmolfoot.com/ who not only makes your boots fit correctly, he can shape your boots so that you/your legs align correctly with your skis. GMOL is right at the mountain at Stratton so that you actually ski with the fitter as the work progresses. I've had friends who have had Greg work on their boots but I have not felt the need. Treated my Pop to a fitting at GMOL last Christmas. He's always had a poor fit in stock boots, and was at the point where he would only ski 3 or 4 runs a day because of the pain. He can now be out all day with no problem. Dan Kewl, I hear similar reports from my friends who have gone there. Even though I have never been in his shop, I can't recommend him highly enough. VtSkier |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
In article , says...
There is one in Aspen whose name escapes me and Greg Hoffman at Green Mountain Orthotics Lab http://www.gmolfoot.com/ who not only makes your boots fit correctly, he can shape your boots so that you/your legs align correctly with your skis. GMOL is right at the mountain at Stratton so that you actually ski with the fitter as the work progresses. I've had friends who have had Greg work on their boots but I have not felt the need. Well, the bootfitter at Wilderness House is only in on Tuesdays, and I'd rather work with someone right on a mountain where we can tweak together, so I made an appointment for this morning at GMOL. (Stupidly, I didn't feed the cats, so rather than staying to enjoy the aftermath of the blizzard, I had to drive home this evening.) Greg is off at some big conference till February, but Bill there took good care of me. He's not a podiatrist, though, and I had some confusion about that; when I made the appointment, I asked if making an appointment with someone else was losing out on Greg's ability to prescribe corrective (as opposed to compensative) footbeds, and was told that "so-and-so is also an orthopod"; I wasn't sure if that was the same as an orthopedist (doctor) or a pedorthist (footbed maker), and so when I asked Bill about corrective insoles for daily wear and he demurred, I didn't press the matter. That said, I learned: 1. Yes, 26 is a very aggressive fit for my foot size. Not too small, necessarily, but as he put it, a "race fit" - it's quite snug for a beginner and it's going to take some getting used to, and some stretching. However, I can move my toes vertically and horizontally when I'm flexing the boot, so it's ok. 2. Arch cramps can be caused by calf tightness. Arch cramps can be relieved by calf stretches. 3. Nerves don't cross, so lateral numbness means lateral nerve compression, and ditto for medial numbness. The Sugarloaf bootfitters weren't sure about that, so had we spent some time grinding out the medial ankle pressure points in the hopes it might alleviate the lateral numbness. No such luck. 4. Much of the numbness is worse when I'm sitting, say for lunch, and that's just the way it's going to be with tight boots. Solution: Take off the boots when I'm sitting, say for lunch. 5. I have a leg-length discrepancy. Actually, as we discussed, I know that I don't really; when I go to PT and she stretches my hip out properly, my apparent leg length is fine. But, as he pointed out, "that's nice." In general, I'm always going to be tighter on the one side, so he added a post to one boot and planed the other sole so I'd feel balanced. Should some miracle occur and I become permanently more flexible, he'll just do the converse. 6. An interesting test that covers both internal canting and external sole thickness is to rock from side to side in the boots and feel the edges of your "ski" (e.g. boot). When both boots lift and lower at the same time, you're all set. 7. Despite what some bootfitters say, it IS a good idea to break in the boots by walking around the house. Bill said he doesn't even ski in boots till he's given them 10-12 hours. Total bill was roughly $300 for custom footbeds, heel lifts, and labor for the post, sole planing and grinding. As far as I can tell, my boots are now as good as they're going to get from modifications, and it's time to ski and walk as much as I can in them. Thanks, all, for the suggestions, and I'll report back later in the season! -- Jay Levitt | Wellesley, MA | Hi! Faster: jay at jay dot eff-em | Where are we going? http://www.jay.fm | Why am I in this handbasket? |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Jay Levitt wrote:
[snip] 1. Yes, 26 is a very aggressive fit for my foot size. Not too small, necessarily, but as he put it, a "race fit" - it's quite snug for a beginner and it's going to take some getting used to, and some stretching. However, I can move my toes vertically and horizontally when I'm flexing the boot, so it's ok. [snip] 4. Much of the numbness is worse when I'm sitting, say for lunch, and that's just the way it's going to be with tight boots. Solution: Take off the boots when I'm sitting, say for lunch. Why do you _want_ a race fit? I mean, they're your feet, but you're a beginner, so what are you getting out of it besides a certain amount of hassle and discomfort? -- Mary Malmros Some days you're the windshield, other days you're the bug. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
says... 1. Yes, 26 is a very aggressive fit for my foot size. Not too small, necessarily, but as he put it, a "race fit" - it's quite snug for a beginner and it's going to take some getting used to, and some stretching. However, I can move my toes vertically and horizontally when I'm flexing the boot, so it's ok. [snip] 4. Much of the numbness is worse when I'm sitting, say for lunch, and that's just the way it's going to be with tight boots. Solution: Take off the boots when I'm sitting, say for lunch. Why do you _want_ a race fit? I mean, they're your feet, but you're a beginner, so what are you getting out of it besides a certain amount of hassle and discomfort? Well, I didn't, necessarily... I had originally been fitted with size 27 Performa 7's at Sunday River. When I complained of numbness at Sugarloaf, the bootfitter told me that I should really be in a 26, so I took him at his word and got the free exchange (since both are ASC resorts), and took the opportunity to upgrade to X-Waves, which are also a tighter fit. Now I find out that that's not necessarily true, but I'd already driven three hours from Boston to Stratton, and so I would have had to go back home, drive 5 to Sugarloaf, exchange the boots yet again, and then go back to Stratton for the footbeds. I suspect in the long run I'll be happier with the tighter boots, and the pedorthist said they aren't tight enough to actually cause problems, just some temporary discomfort, so I decided to stay with them. They don't hurt, or anything - they're just snug, and my toes have no room when I'm not flexing. Plus, I can really feel the difference in control and feedback, though it's hard to say how much of that is X-Wave vs. Performa, and how much is 26 vs. 27. -- Jay Levitt | Wellesley, MA | Hi! Faster: jay at jay dot eff-em | Where are we going? http://www.jay.fm | Why am I in this handbasket? |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Jay Levitt wrote:
In article , says... There is one in Aspen whose name escapes me and Greg Hoffman at Green Mountain Orthotics Lab http://www.gmolfoot.com/ who not only makes your boots fit correctly, he can shape your boots so that you/your legs align correctly with your skis. GMOL is right at the mountain at Stratton so that you actually ski with the fitter as the work progresses. I've had friends who have had Greg work on their boots but I have not felt the need. Well, the bootfitter at Wilderness House is only in on Tuesdays, and I'd rather work with someone right on a mountain where we can tweak together, so I made an appointment for this morning at GMOL. (Stupidly, I didn't feed the cats, so rather than staying to enjoy the aftermath of the blizzard, I had to drive home this evening.) Greg is off at some big conference till February, but Bill there took good care of me. He's not a podiatrist, though, and I had some confusion about that; when I made the appointment, I asked if making an appointment with someone else was losing out on Greg's ability to prescribe corrective (as opposed to compensative) footbeds, and was told that "so-and-so is also an orthopod"; I wasn't sure if that was the same as an orthopedist (doctor) or a pedorthist (footbed maker), and so when I asked Bill about corrective insoles for daily wear and he demurred, I didn't press the matter. That said, I learned: 1. Yes, 26 is a very aggressive fit for my foot size. Not too small, necessarily, but as he put it, a "race fit" - it's quite snug for a beginner and it's going to take some getting used to, and some stretching. However, I can move my toes vertically and horizontally when I'm flexing the boot, so it's ok. 2. Arch cramps can be caused by calf tightness. Arch cramps can be relieved by calf stretches. 3. Nerves don't cross, so lateral numbness means lateral nerve compression, and ditto for medial numbness. The Sugarloaf bootfitters weren't sure about that, so had we spent some time grinding out the medial ankle pressure points in the hopes it might alleviate the lateral numbness. No such luck. 4. Much of the numbness is worse when I'm sitting, say for lunch, and that's just the way it's going to be with tight boots. Solution: Take off the boots when I'm sitting, say for lunch. 5. I have a leg-length discrepancy. Actually, as we discussed, I know that I don't really; when I go to PT and she stretches my hip out properly, my apparent leg length is fine. But, as he pointed out, "that's nice." In general, I'm always going to be tighter on the one side, so he added a post to one boot and planed the other sole so I'd feel balanced. Should some miracle occur and I become permanently more flexible, he'll just do the converse. 6. An interesting test that covers both internal canting and external sole thickness is to rock from side to side in the boots and feel the edges of your "ski" (e.g. boot). When both boots lift and lower at the same time, you're all set. 7. Despite what some bootfitters say, it IS a good idea to break in the boots by walking around the house. Bill said he doesn't even ski in boots till he's given them 10-12 hours. Total bill was roughly $300 for custom footbeds, heel lifts, and labor for the post, sole planing and grinding. As far as I can tell, my boots are now as good as they're going to get from modifications, and it's time to ski and walk as much as I can in them. Thanks, all, for the suggestions, and I'll report back later in the season! Please do report back. $300 is a great deal if everything works as advertised. A full treatment at SureFoot is $200 with much less customizing. VtSkier |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
nervous newbie | Bob | Alpine Skiing | 18 | February 6th 05 06:31 AM |
toes sticking out over board edge | Rick Spencer | Snowboarding | 3 | January 2nd 04 09:51 PM |