SkiBanter

SkiBanter (http://www.skibanter.com/index.php)
-   Nordic Skiing (http://www.skibanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not? (http://www.skibanter.com/showthread.php?t=17220)

[email protected] February 14th 08 08:57 PM

Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
 
Does anybody know if there's a way to tell if wax is high fluoro or
not? I wonder because I purchased some HF Toko wax on E-Bay and now
I'm wondering what would stop someone from putting in regular
Hydrocarbon wax and passing it off as HF. Also, it seems likely that
sometimes one could separate a wax from it's labeled container, so I
was wondering if there are any characteristics -- smell, granularity,
weight, etc. that might indicate a wax's fluoro content.

[email protected] February 14th 08 09:45 PM

Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
 
Short of a chemical analysis, wax two skis, one with the eBay purchase,
the other with a store bought version and go ski. My experience on
eBay is that switching is not likely, since it's just too much trouble
all around. Fraud there is more likely in just not receiving your order.


wrote:

Does anybody know if there's a way to tell if wax is high fluoro or
not? I wonder because I purchased some HF Toko wax on E-Bay and now
I'm wondering what would stop someone from putting in regular
Hydrocarbon wax and passing it off as HF. Also, it seems likely that
sometimes one could separate a wax from it's labeled container, so I
was wondering if there are any characteristics -- smell, granularity,
weight, etc. that might indicate a wax's fluoro content.


Jay W February 14th 08 11:08 PM

Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
 
On Feb 14, 4:45*pm, wrote:
Short of a chemical analysis, wax two skis, one with the eBay purchase,
the other with a store bought version and go ski. *My experience on
eBay is that switching is not likely, since it's just too much trouble
all around. Fraud there is more likely in just not receiving your order.


When you melt the Swix LF waxes they smell different than hydrocarbon
waxes. I haven't noticed the same thing with Toko HF waxes. I would
think a drop of water would bead up more on an HF waxed ski, but I
don't know if it's easy to actually see. An HF wax is usually softer
(fingernail test) than hydrocarbon wax.

Jay

[email protected] February 15th 08 01:47 AM

Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
 
On Feb 14, 7:08*pm, Jay W wrote:
On Feb 14, 4:45*pm, wrote:

Short of a chemical analysis, wax two skis, one with the eBay purchase,
the other with a store bought version and go ski. *My experience on
eBay is that switching is not likely, since it's just too much trouble
all around. Fraud there is more likely in just not receiving your order.


When you melt the Swix LF waxes they smell different than hydrocarbon
waxes. I haven't noticed the same thing with Toko HF waxes. I would
think a drop of water would bead up more on an HF waxed ski, but I
don't know if it's easy to actually see. An HF wax is usually softer
(fingernail test) than hydrocarbon wax.

Jay


Thank you very much for your reply.

jeff potter February 15th 08 03:58 AM

Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
 
What about the sparkles effect when ironing a fluoro wax? I have some
HF FastWax that occasionally irridesces. That makes me wonder---is
that the fluoro component? Is that IT? (Not much...) I thought that
was the cool thing about ironing the pure fluoro. (Haven't hardly used
it.) ----JP

[email protected] February 15th 08 04:41 AM

Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
 
What was the auction number?

wrote:

On Feb 14, 7:08*pm, Jay W wrote:
On Feb 14, 4:45*pm, wrote:

Short of a chemical analysis, wax two skis, one with the eBay purchase,
the other with a store bought version and go ski. *My experience on
eBay is that switching is not likely, since it's just too much trouble
all around. Fraud there is more likely in just not receiving your order.


When you melt the Swix LF waxes they smell different than hydrocarbon
waxes. I haven't noticed the same thing with Toko HF waxes. I would
think a drop of water would bead up more on an HF waxed ski, but I
don't know if it's easy to actually see. An HF wax is usually softer
(fingernail test) than hydrocarbon wax.

Jay


Thank you very much for your reply.


Gunde February 15th 08 05:11 PM

Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
 
When you melt a high fluro wax into your ski base, it acts differently
as a liquid compared to a carbon wax. The fluro has an unusual stringy
texture, while a carbon looks more homogenous as a liquid. I am not
explaining it well, but you will recognize it whe you see it.

highpeaksnordic February 16th 08 12:25 AM

Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
 
On Feb 14, 4:57*pm, wrote:
Does anybody know if there's a way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
I'm wondering what would stop someone from putting in regular
Hydrocarbon wax and passing it off as HF.


I'd guess the simplest way to check would be to notice whether the wax
was "strapped" to the cardboard hanger w/ the plastic strip that Toko
uses. Toko uses that plastic case and the cardboard is attached to
the case; the strip goes around both pieces. it If the plastic strip
was still intact, I would believe that it was what it says it is.

I have seen some Toko wax (the 100 gram bars) packed in a ziploc bag,
which simply has a stick-on label - I guess you take that purchase on
faith or buy from your local, reputable shop!

- Bob


[email protected] February 16th 08 03:25 AM

Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
 
Burning a fluoro wax should release CO2, H20, and pure F2 which has a
distinct smell (and is very toxic, too). Burning a hydrocarbon wax
would release only C02 and H20.

Theoretically, one can burn a piece of a known HC wax, and a piece of
a known HF wax, and see the difference in the smell. Then, burn the
uknown wax and see if it smells like the HF.

Practically, this is not recommended because of the toxicity of F2.


[email protected] February 16th 08 03:36 AM

Any way to tell if wax is high fluoro or not?
 
Method 2.

Wax a surface with a known HC wax, wax the same surface the same way
with a known HF wax, and wax the same surface the same way with wax
X.

Deposit 10 droplets of water of the same size onto patches HC, HF, and
X.

First, see if there is a difference between droplets HC and HF. If
there is, the method kinda works.

Second see if droplets X look more like droplets HC or more like
droplets HF.


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:08 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SkiBanter.com